Why review gating is in the news again
On November 13, 2026, SmartCompany reported on a practice that a lot of business owners use without realizing it: review gating. The story looked at salon and booking software that can set a minimum star rating before a customer is ever prompted to post a review on Google. In plain terms, the happy customers get sent to Google, and everyone else gets steered somewhere private.
The article was written about Australian businesses, but the software features it describes are sold worldwide, and the rules it points to are Google's own. One marketer quoted in the piece called gating a "grey area." Another said many businesses may not realize it's a problem at all. That second point is the one I see most often.
What Google and the FTC actually say
Google's contribution policy, which covers reviews on Google Maps and your Business Profile, is clear. As quoted in the SmartCompany report, it prohibits businesses from "discouraging or prohibiting negative reviews, or selectively soliciting positive reviews from customers." You can read the full Google prohibited and restricted content policy under its fake engagement section.
Here in the U.S., the Federal Trade Commission says the same thing in plainer words. Its guide on soliciting and paying for online reviews tells businesses: "Don't ask for reviews only from customers you think will leave positive ones." The same guide says not to condition an incentive on a review being positive, and not to ask your staff to review your business unless they disclose that you employ them.
The FTC also has a formal rule on consumer reviews and testimonials, published in August 2024, that targets fake reviews and buying reviews that depend on what they say. Gating is one piece of a bigger picture: reviews are supposed to reflect real customers, good and bad.
How gating sneaks into everyday tools
Most owners I talk with never set out to game anything. Gating usually arrives as a friendly-sounding feature. Watch for these:
- "Rate us first" screens. A text or email asks for a star rating, then only sends 4- and 5-star customers to your Google review link.
- Rating thresholds in booking or POS software. A setting with a name like "rating boost" or "smart review routing" that only prompts customers above a certain score.
- Private feedback forms for unhappy customers. Collecting complaints privately is fine. Using that form to keep those customers away from public review sites is the problem.
- Hand-picked asks. Only handing review cards to the regulars you know love you counts too, even without software.
None of this has to be malicious to be a policy issue. If the result is that only happy people get invited, that's selective soliciting.
Why honest reviews work better anyway
A wall of perfect 5-star reviews can look less believable, not more. A few 3- and 4-star reviews with thoughtful replies from you show real customers and a real owner who cares. Your replies are public, so every potential customer reads them.
Gating also teaches you less. When you invite everyone, the occasional critical review points to something fixable: a slow callback, a confusing invoice, a missing page on your website. And you protect the profile you've worked hard on, because Google can remove reviews that violate its policy.
What this means for your business
Here's the checklist I'd run this week:
- Open your review settings. In your booking, POS, CRM or review app, look for star-rating filters, thresholds or "routing" options, and turn them off so every customer gets the same invite.
- Ask everyone the same way. One message, one link to your Google review page, sent to every completed job or visit. Timing can be consistent, like the day after service.
- Keep private feedback, but don't block the public path. If you want a feedback form, offer it alongside the Google link, not instead of it.
- Skip incentives tied to good reviews. And don't have staff or family post reviews.
- Reply to every review. Thank the happy ones. For critical ones, stay calm, own what you can and invite the person to call.
This is a big part of the reputation management work I do for clients: setting up an honest review request that runs on its own, and keeping up with replies.
If you run a business here in Surprise or anywhere in the West Valley, your Google reviews often decide whether a neighbor calls you or the next listing down. I'm happy to look over your review setup and your Google Business Profile with you. Call or text me at 480-550-2871.
Frequently asked questions
What is review gating?
Review gating is screening customers before inviting them to leave a public review, so only people likely to be positive are sent to sites like Google. It often works through a star-rating question first, with happy customers routed to Google and unhappy ones routed to a private form.
Is review gating against Google's rules?
Yes. Google's contribution policy prohibits businesses from discouraging negative reviews or selectively soliciting positive reviews from customers. Reviews that violate the policy can be removed. The safe approach is to send the same review invitation to every customer, whatever their experience was.
Can I still collect private feedback from unhappy customers?
Yes, as long as it doesn't replace the public review option. Offer a private feedback form alongside your Google review link, not in place of it. That way unhappy customers can reach you directly, but nobody is kept away from posting a public review.
How should a Surprise, AZ business ask for Google reviews?
Send every customer the same short message with a direct link to your Google review page, ideally soon after the job or visit. Don't filter by rating, don't offer rewards for positive reviews, and reply to every review you receive. Consistency builds a believable profile over time.
Sources
- SmartCompany: Behind the stars: Review-gating software raises questions for small businesses
- Google: Prohibited and restricted content (contribution policy)
- FTC: Soliciting and paying for online reviews: a guide for marketers
- Federal Register: Trade Regulation Rule on the Use of Consumer Reviews and Testimonials
